Reading outline · Self & personhood
What does it mean to be a person?
Body, continuity and the language of self.
The Gita distinguishes embodied life from that which Krishna describes as enduring. The Dhammapada directs attention to self-discipline. Genesis speaks of life through a creation narrative. Do not treat every occurrence of “self” as a claim about the same metaphysical entity; these passages invite different questions.
In this reading
Bhagavad Gita · Hinduism
Krishna’s response to Arjuna’s grief and concern about killing.
Read passage · Bhagavad Gita →“The Holy One said,—‘Thou mournest those that deserve not to be mourned. Thou speakest also the words of the (so-called) wise. Those, however, that are (really) wise, grieve neither for the dead nor for the living. It is not that. I or you or those rulers of men never were, or that all of us …
Dhammapada · Buddhism
A practical exhortation about one’s own support and discipline.
Read passage · Dhammapada →Self is the lord of self, who else could be the lord? With self well subdued, a man finds a lord such as few can find.
Bible · Christianity
Human life described through earth and divine breath.
Read passage · Bible →The LORD God formed man from the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul.
What changes when we read them together?
The English word self is not a sufficient bridge between metaphysical description, practical self-discipline and a creation narrative. Its meaning depends on the passage in which it appears.
Words in these readings
- Embodiment
- Read Krishna’s reply together with Arjuna’s grief and objection.
- One’s own support
- Müller’s Dhammapada selection is a practical exhortation.
- Breath of life
- Genesis uses narrative imagery of earth and breath in its account of human life.
Sources & reading notes
These are selected passages, not a complete account of any tradition. Introductions and explanations are editorial writing. Quotations use the named translations; an ellipsis marks a shortened selection.
All edition sources & licensing